Prevention and Response to GBV in conflict-related emergencies

This topic was posted the General discussion forum area and has 6 replies.

You can also post a reply by emailing post78@forums.alnap.org. See our forum guidelines for more details.

Suzanne WILLIAMS

Suzanne WILLIAMS

Goukamma Consulting

1 July 2010, 15:10

Is it possible, is it effective, to work on changing attitudes and beliefs as part of humanitarian action in the midst of conflict, and/or post-conflict?

Do you have good practice exampes of innovative work on awareness-raising, or attitudinal change, in humanitarian interventions in relation to gender-based violence in particular? Anywhere in the world. Or, if not, then in relation to other sectors/issues - health, hygience, WATSAN, shelter etc. I'm conducting research on whether work on attitudinal change about gender-based violence is possible/effective in humanitarian relief - in camps or settlements or host communities. The focus is on the building of a sense of personal and individual responsibility and empowerment to prevent GBV, and is based on a model developed in South Asia. Responses of all kinds welcome!

Travis Montgomery

Travis Montgomery

US Army

1 July 2010, 17:33

My experience is in SW Asia; actually observing an increase of GBV increased with most job programs. The second and third order consequences increased completion as women vied for positions in an already limited environment. Indirect attempts to influence were far more successful. The most successful programs supported the community as a whole with women in particular benefiting more. Increasing overall access to education, healthcare, and essential services promoted the community while benefiting susceptible groups to include women.

In Iraq's Kurdistan region there has been a campaign by the Kurdish Parliament to decrease FGM, actually passing legislation beyond the Iraqi National Parliament's law. The Kurdish controlled areas possess greater stability and a vested interest in changing attitudes, beliefs, and cultural practices. The desire for International aid and development is a good motivator if contingent on altering a brehavior.

Mireia Cano

Mireia Cano

Senior Gender in Emergencies Specialist, CARE International

2 July 2010, 16:11

Dear Suzanne,

Your question -copied below- is indeed a very relevant one. The report from CARE's Strategic Impact Inquiry on Women's Empowerment ("The Courage to Change") has raised many challenges in our quest to be accountable for impact on the drivers of gender inequity -which we firmly belief to be at the heart of GBV- and led to deep questioning of our assumptions about the changes (short and long term) we are seeking and the ways in which we measure change. Please keep us informed of your research and do not hesitate to contact us for further details (or if you want a copy of the report): cano@careinternational.org. Thank you.

Suzanne WILLIAMS

Suzanne WILLIAMS

(Topic starter)

Goukamma Consulting

3 July 2010, 12:42

Dear Mireia,
Many thanks for your response and I'll be emailing you separately about the report. I will certainly keep you informed about the research, and indeed CARE is one of the agencies on the top of my list in terms of youir reputation about GBV work. There is always resistance to trying longer-term solutions in the midst of humanitarian response - most agencies do buy into 'the myth of speed', and most humanitarian workers feel the pressure from many quarters, includng their own genuine sense of wanting to respond immediately in a crisis, to act and to be seen to be acting. In the process, social complexity is lost. More in an email! thanks for response. suzanne

Erin Kenny

Erin Kenny

Gender-Based Violence Specialist, UN Population Fund (UNFPA)

5 July 2010, 02:24

Dear Suzanne,

Great question. In fact, we are well-served in this area of work to look at the possible opportunities presented by the social upheaval that often attends conflict or disaster to promote changes in attitudes, beliefs and practices. We can often witness women engaged in different types of work, with opportunities for such things as literacy education and livelihood programs, as well as in positions of greater (comparative) power in the context of displacement when feeding the family and ensuring access to healthcare are prioritized.

In Liberia, I had the privilege of launching a program in communities of newly-returned populations (with high levels of women and children who had been associated with the fighting forces). Given the significant transportation challenges and recognition that both our behavior-change interventions and direct survivor support programs could not conform to a 9-5 schedule, we placed two social workers - one male and one female - in the communities that we were supporting. Not only were these social workers able to implement program components and be available to receive cases at any time of the day or night, they were also able to model a new way of interacting with equal respect and equal support.

At UNFPA, our staff and partners are present in a country before, during and after the crisis. We work principally with civil society and government actors to ensure national ownership of all initiatives. In this way, global standards of addressing GBV in humanitarian contexts (e.g. the IASC GBV Guidelines and related tools) can be readily filtered through women's groups and others to ensure populations of concern for addressing GBV can readily identify with the aid that is available to them. In this way, humanitarian aid that seeks to prevent new incidents of GBV and provide comprehensive care for survivors does not merely live in the realm of quick aid, but becomes a part and parcel of good programming, transcending the emergency or post-emergency periods.

I hope this helps address your question Suzanne. Best of luck with your research and do let us know how it's going.

Erin Kenny

WikiRandy Fisher

WikiRandy Fisher

Organization Development, WikiEducator / OER Foundation

9 July 2010, 21:38

Very interesting question and replies - thanks.

From the comments and sharing of experiences, I see several possibilities here. One, is the convening of a panel to speak at a conference on experiences had, lessons learned.

The other possibility is to create an active repository of good practices, that can be shared, explored, re-used and adapted to support users in this community and the larger community.

You may wish to adapt the model that I've used working with the Commonwealth of Learning (COL), for developing effective learning programs for community radio, for example. We used WikiEducator.org (a COL project, and now an independent project of the Open Education Resource Foundation) as a living repository for the development and sharing of good practices and learning materials. It has worked well, and led to substantive sharing, networking and learning - helping the community to grow and realize its own power and influence, as a force for support, change and community participation and ownership. http://www.wikieducator.org/Community_Media

Feel free to contact me if you'd like more details.

- Randy Fisher (aka WikiRandy)

Suzanne WILLIAMS

Suzanne WILLIAMS

(Topic starter)

Goukamma Consulting

10 July 2010, 10:42

Dear Erin,
Many thanks for your helpful response.
Certainly a key factor for successful work for attitude and behaviour change is presence in the country pre- during and post emergency intervention and good relationships with local NGOs and community groups as well as other civil society actors and government. And as your example of Liberia shows, the building of real relationships with individuals and groups through having dedicated workers in the settlements, camps or communities. I would very much like to know more about this work - the Liberia experience - and indeed other initiatives of UNFPA, as I know that you have been at the forefront of work on GBV.

Is the experience written up? Or could we have a further dialogue on email and/or skype? I am very keen to share findings of the research as it goes along, and maintain a dialogue with colleagues who are interested in it.

I will be doing some field research in Sri Lanka and Pakistan in September, where the VAW campaign is active in conflicted areas, and will hopefully have input from others working on the campaign in the DRC.

Post a reply

You need an account before you can post a reply.

If you already have an account, please sign in.

If you don't have an account, you can create an account now.

Share and bookmark